|
|
|
CONFERENCE REPORT
Labouring Lives
Harry Knowles
'Labouring Lives' was the autumn conference for the
British Society for the Study of Labour History organised by the University
of Manchester Communist Party Biographical Project and the Dictionary
of Labour Biography. It was held in Manchester, 3 November 2001.
|
The purpose of the 'Labouring Lives' conference was to explore the
various ways of researching and writing the lives of people involved
in labour and other radical social movements. It was organised around
four themes: suffrage history; autobiography; biography; and the
international scene. |
1
|
|
The speakers list included
the likes of John Saville, David Howell, Bryan Palmer, Shelia
Rowbotham (an unfortunate late withdrawal due to illness), Stefan
Berger, Sandra Holten, Kevin Morgan and Nina Fishmen. The venue
was the Mechanics Institute, Princess Street, Manchestera
plaque on the outside wall reminded all who entered that this
had been the site of the First Intercontinental Trade Union Congress
in 1868. Two panels of speakers ran concurrently in both the morning
(writing suffrage histories and comparative/international) and
afternoon (collective biography/biography and autobiography) sessions.
|
2
|
| The keynote address was delivered
by the rather spritely, mid-octogenarian John Saville, who provided
a most entertaining and intriguing reminiscence of his 'labouring
life'. A student at the London School of Economics and a Communist
Party member when war broke out in 1939, Saville joined the British
Army. In a very amusing account of this period, he recalled how
he repeatedly refused a commission in defiance of the Party directive
and in the face of persistent demands of his commanding officer.
It was only after the Army threatened to post him to a base in Iceland
that Saville relented, though he still believed he could serve the
Party better from the ranks. |
3
|
| As might have been expected,
given the reputation of many of those on the speakers' list, the
papers were of an impressive standard, and it was a revelation to
me to learn of the variety of approaches British labour historians
have adopted to incorporate biographical/autobiographical methodology
in the writing of history. For example, Bryan Palmer delivered a
convincing re-interpretation the origins of early American Bolshevism
through a biographical assessment of the life of James P. Cannon
whilst Nina Fishman examined underlying similarities in the lives
of three Communist miners' leaders in three different countries.
|
4
|
| David Howell employed a biographical
approach to re-open the history of the British Labour Party of the
early 1930s through the lives of labour renegades. Stefan Berger
analysed seven British and nine German autobiographies of social
democratic activists of the inter-war period in an attempt to establish
how they constructed the relationship between their social narratives
and the imagined collectivities of nation and class. |
5
|
| Amongst the younger historians,
two papers particularly stood out. Both papers revealed new insights
into the nature of industrial activism in the immediate past era
of British mining unionism. Keith Gildart's paper was based on an
examination of the autobiographies of miners from the previously
under-researched coalfields in North Wales. Meg Allen examined the
construction of collective resistance during the 1984-85 Miners
Strike through the recollections of activism of women participants.
|
6
|
|
As one of the three of four 'internationals' represented at the
conference, I cannot speak highly enough of the hospitality extended
by the conference organisers and the degree of camaraderie experienced
during the conference and in my all too short stay in Manchester.
The conviviality experienced over a few pints at The Old Monkey
on arrival and several more at the post-conference get-together
at the Lass o'Gowrie will long be remembered.
|
7
|
| Manchester is indeed a 'mecca'
for labour historians. My hotel had been a cotton warehouse in a
previous life whilst the conference venue itself at 103 Princess
Street also housed the Labour History Archive & Study Centre
managed by the John Rylans Library. The Centre is the only specialist
repository for the political wing of the labour movement. Its holdings
include the records of the working-class political organisations
from the Chartists to Tony Blair, the archives of the Labour Party
and of the Communist Party of Great Britain. There are also assortment
of personal papers of radical politicians, writers and left-wing
organisations along with collections of banners, photographs, prints,
ceramics, and ephemera from over 200 years of labour movement history.
The John Rylans Library, a particularly impressive example of modern
Gothic architecture, also has collections of labour movement records
and manuscripts. |
8
|
| Finally,
a stroll from the centre of the city down to Bridge Street on the
Left Bank will reveal the impressive Pump House Peoples' History
Museum which houses the galleries and education service of the National
Museum of Labour History. The Peoples' History Museum offers reconstructions
of working life (the 'tramping artisan' exhibit was particularly
revealing), documents, objects, and a claimed world-renowned collection
of banners. Exhibits include the role of cotton manufacturing and
political radicalism in the early years of the industrial revolution
in Manchester, the growth of trade unions and friendly societies,
the evolution of socialism and birth of the Labour Party, the history
of the campaign for women's vote, coal miners and their communities
from the 1790s to the 1990s, and how workers spent their leisure
timefootball, sea-side holidays and music. |
9
|
| All of this is housed in a former
Edwardian hydraulic pumping station. On the day I visited, one of
the highlights was the obvious interest expressed in the exhibits
of Manchester's working-class history by a succession of visiting
school groups. It made me wonder why, with our own rich traditions
in labour history, we lack a similar venue. |
10
|
|
Content in the History Cooperative database is intended for
personal, noncommercial use only. You may not reproduce,
publish, distribute, transmit, participate in the transfer or
sale of, modify, create derivative works from, display, or in any
way exploit the History Cooperative database in whole or in part
without the written permission of the copyright holder.
|