|
|
|
Scrutinizing
the Immigrant Working Class
Alexandra Minna Stern, University of Michigan
FAIRCHILD, AMY L. Science at the Borders:
Immigrant Medical Inspection and the Shaping of the Modern Industrial
Labor Force, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2003.
xiv + 385 pp. Illustrations, charts, appendices, notes, index. $48.00
(cloth), ISBN 0-8018-7080-1.
|
|
|
In this extensively researched monograph,
Amy L. Fairchild analyzes data from immigrant medical inspections
conducted by the United States Public Health Service, in conjunction
with the Immigration and Naturalization Service, between 1891
and the late 1920s. Smartly combining quantitative and qualitative
methods, Fairchild provides a detailed portrait of inspections
at all ports of entry into the United States, from Ellis Island
and Angel Island on the two coasts, to Galveston, Texas, and Port
Huron, Michigan, on the southern and northern borders. The result
is an informative text that sheds light on the myriad ways in
which class, race, and disease helped to determine regional variations
in medical inspections, while, at the same time, being continuously
redefined in response to shifting congeries of ideas about
human and social difference.
|
1
|
|
One of the most innovative aspects
of Fairchild's work is her reinterpretation of the medical inspection
not as an act principally aimed at exclusion and deportation,
but as a ritualized passage of integration and inclusion into
American society. Fairchild argues that the inspection functioned
primarily as a disciplinary process, in which the future industrial
working class was exposed to the rhythms and logic of assembly
line production and scientific management: "first and foremost,
then, the immigrant medical inspection became an important part
of a subtle yet pervasive nationwide endeavor to discipline the
labor force" (7). As they filed through the "line" at Ellis Island
and were scrutinized by the gaze of health examiners, many newcomersÑespecially
those from Eastern and Southern EuropeÑtook the initial steps
toward assuming their places at the lower rungs of the new industrial
economy.
|
2
|
|
Although devoting most of her attention
to Ellis Island, which received the majority of the twenty-five
million immigrants who arrived in the United States from 1891 to
1930, Fairchild is careful to emphasize the varying receptions that
different ethnic and racialized groups received along the West coast
and southern border. For example, through statistical analysis,
Fairchild demonstrates that, from 1916 to 1930, Asians and some
Southern and Eastern European groups (specifically Croatians, Slovenians,
Slovaks, Roumanians, and Hebrews, as classified by officialdom)
registered the highest aggregate rates of certification for an excludable
medical condition and subsequent deportation. Moreover, the Chinese
were also certified at much higher rates than average for conditions
defined as loathsome and dangerous contagious diseases, a pattern
explained in part by deep-seated Sinophobia, particularly in western
states such as California. |
. . . |
There are about 580 more words in this article.
Please log in (or, if you are not yet an
authorized user, please go to the
User Setup page) to gain full access rights. Or if you're already logged in register your subscription.
|