|
|
|
Looking for Laura Secord on the Web: Using a Famous Figure from the War of 1812 as a Model for Evaluating Historical Web Sites
Marsha Ann Tate The Pennsylvania State University
|
LAURA INGERSOLL SECORD was, admittedly, a well-known historical
figure—at least in Canada over a century before the development
of the World Wide Web. In 1860, she first achieved widespread notoriety
in her adopted homeland of Canada (she was born in Massachusetts)
when a deed she performed for the British army during the War of
1812 was publicly recognized by the Prince of Wales. The deed for
which Laura received fame, albeit relatively little fortune (100
pounds sterling from the Prince), was walking approximately 20 miles
through inhospitable terrain to alert British Lieutenant John Fitzgibbons
that American troops were preparing to launch an attack on the British
garrison at Beaver Dams, Upper Canada in late June 1813. However,
as the diverse accounts of Laura Secord's journey detailed in a
later section of this essay will demonstrate, this seemingly straightforward
chronology of events has undergone a vast number of iterations over
the years. Indeed, it would even eventually secure Laura Secord
a hallowed place within the Pantheon of Canadian heroes and heroines.
|
1
|
|
Over the years, as detailed in Appendix
A, Laura Secord's journey has inspired a myriad of books, plays,
music, stamps, and more. Since 1913, moreover, Laura Secord has
served as the namesake for a popular chain of candy stores located
throughout Canada.
1
Even today, the Laura Secord legend remains alive and well thanks
to a recent spate of children's books and scholarly works devoted
to various aspects of her life. Meanwhile, she also continues to
inspire contemporary artists, including an upscale sock puppet sculptor—among
others. However, despite the availability of an eclectic array of
print and other materials related to Laura Secord, for many individuals
the World Wide Web will serve as the principal, or in some cases,
the only source of information about her exploits or even about
other aspects of the War of 1812.
|
2
|
|
Given this fact of modern life, this
essay will explore the cyberspace repository of information about
Laura Secord in an attempt to answer the following questions: 1)
How is Laura Secord's journey depicted on web pages/sites? 2) How
are the web-based depictions of Laura Secord similar/different from
accounts found in print sources? and, 3) In what, if any, other
aspects do the web-based resources related to Laura Secord differ
from their print counterparts? Using the web research conducted
on Laura Secord as a basis for discussion, the essay's final section
will address the major issues that should be taken into account
when conducting web-based historical research. It should also be
emphasized that although this essay focuses exclusively upon one
single historical figure, the methods used to help determine the
reliability of web-based resources devoted to Laura Secord are equally
applicable to other historical web sites regardless of topic area.
|
3
|
| |
|
Laura Secord's World
|
|
|
Before delving into the questions
outlined above, however, it is first important to place Laura Secord
within the historical context of her times. It is equally important
to briefly address the symbolic role Laura Secord has played in
helping foster a sense of Canadian identity in the years following
the War of 1812. In Flames Across the Border: The Canadian-American
Tragedy, 1813–1814, a print history of the War of 1812,
Canadian historian Pierre Berton relates that in the early years
of the 19th century, three-fifths of the population of Upper Canada
(present day Ontario) were immigrants from the United States, "lured
north of the border by cheap land and low taxes" (p. 3). Fellow
Canadian author, Christopher Moore, further describes the exile
of at least fifty thousand residents of the thirteen colonies who
had been loyal to King George during the American Revolution. Most
of these exiles (the United Empire Loyalists) settled in Canada.
Although they assimilated into local societies, and became Nova
Scotian or Upper Canadian, they often preserved specific Loyalist
traditions (Moore, 1994, p. 9).
|
4
|
|
Laura Secord was born in Great Barrington,
Massachusetts on September 13, 1775 to Thomas and Sarah Ingersoll.
Having fought on the side of the colonists during the Revolutionary
War, Thomas eventually earned the rank of Major following his participation
in helping quell Shay's Rebellion. Sarah, his wife, was a daughter
of General John Whiting who fought on the side of the rebels during
the American Revolution. Financial difficulties, a distaste for
American policies, the lure of inexpensive land, or a combination
of the three factors prompted Thomas Ingersoll to move his family
to the Queenston area of Canada in the early 1780s. In 1795 General
Whiting also immigrated to Upper Canada "...where he had obtained
a township grant for settlement" (McKenzie, 1976, p. 405). While
living in Upper Canada, Laura eventually met James Secord, an American-born
merchant and militia volunteer whom she would later marry in 1797.
James Secord was the son of a loyalist officer of Butler's Rangers
who brought the family to Niagara in 1778. At the outbreak of the
War of 1812, Laura was thirty-eight years of age and the mother
of five children, while James was a sergeant in the 1(st)Lincoln
militia (Wallace, 1963; McKenzie, 1976, p. 405).
|
5
|
| |
|
A Legend with a Purpose
|
|
In many respects, Laura Secord serves
as a perfect Canadian heroine. She was a woman who displayed bravery
and tenacity in the face of multiple adversities. More importantly,
she was a Loyalist who assisted the British in their struggle with
the Americans. As Pierre Berton notes, "Laura's story will be used
to underline the growing myth that the War of 1812 was won by true-blue
Canadians—in this case a brave Loyalist housewife who single-handedly
saved the British Army from defeat" (Berton, 1981, p. 83). Tapping
into the Laura Secord legend to help foster a sense of Canadian
nationalism has been an ongoing enterprise within Canada. For example,
to mark the centenary anniversary of the War of 1812, a ceremony
was held at Brock's monument, erected in honor of Major-General
Sir Isaac Brock for his accomplishments at Detroit and Queenston.
The event at Queenston Heights featured a number of respected citizens
of Canada who offered their thoughts on the meaning of the War of
1812 and their relevancy for modern Canadians. One speaker, Dr.
James L. Hughes, a school inspector, argued that teaching about
the lives and deeds of both men and women during the War of 1812
era needed to be an essential component of education for all Canadian
children. He declared:
We should fill each child's life with a splendid courage
that can never be dismayed, by telling how a few determined settlers
scattered widely over a new country successfully repelled invading
armies coming from a country with a population twenty-fold larger.
We should teach reverence not only for manhood but for womanhood
by recounting the terrible hardships endured willingly by Canadian
women generally, as well as proudly relating the noble work done
by individual women, of whom Laura Secord was so conspicuous an
example. (J. L. Hughes, quoted in MacKirdy, Zoltvany, & Moir,
p. 109).
|
6
|
However, a "definitive account" of
Laura Secord's late June 1813 exploits remains elusive, because,
as Pierre Berton relates, "In all her long life, Laura Secord will
tell her story many times, embellishing it here and there, muddying
it more than a little" (Berton, 1981, p. 83). Berton further notes:
Laura will never make clear exactly how she heard the
rumour of an impending attack. ...On this detail she is vague
and contradictory, telling FitzGibbon that her husband learned
of it from an American officer; telling her granddaughter, years
later, that she herself overheard it from enemy soldiers who forced
her to give them dinner in Queenston (Berton, 1981, pp. 83–84).
Since accounts of the event offered by Laura herself varied,
it is not surprising that later accounts of the event offered by
others would differ as well. However, Laura's own varied recollections
merely marked the first of many alternate versions of the story
with new variations appearing on a regular basis to the present
day, especially on the web.
|
7
|
|
Despite the polymorphic nature of
the Laura Secord legend, its role in fostering Canadian nationalism
appears to remain an important underlying incentive for evoking
the legend even on the World Wide Web. But the name and the legend
also serve a number of other purposes: 1) for individual and group
discussions about Canadian history; 2) to provide supplementary
materials for films and television shows related to the War of 1812
and/or Laura Secord; 3) to describe and review books written about
Laura Secord; and finally, 4) to promote products, namely, Laura
Secord chocolates.
|
8
|
|
The web pages/sites surveyed for
this study were identified using a search query for "Laura Secord"
in three well-known web search engines: Google, AllTheWeb.com, and
Yahoo! The contents of the first fifty pages/sites listed in the
search results for each search engine were then examined. Pages/sites
which provided links to other relevant web pages/sites not previously
retrieved via the search engine queries were also visited. In addition
to web-based materials, a number of print works about the War of
1812 and/or Laura Secord were also examined. Thereafter, information
gathered from both formats was compared and contrasted.
|
9
|
|
Before delving into an examination
of the web pages and sites found, it should be noted that virtually
all of the web sources related to Laura Secord were created by Canadians.
Not surprisingly, visitors to these pages/sites are offered a predominantly
Canadian perspective on the War of 1812 and Laura Secord's role
in the conflict. For this reason, while Laura is regarded as a heroine
and patriot by Canadians, her exploits when viewed from an American
perspective may be interpreted quite differently. For example, from
an American standpoint, Laura Secord may arguably have more in common
with Benedict Arnold than someone like Betsy Ross or Molly Pitcher
since she essentially betrayed her country of birth—the United
States—to the enemy, the British. However, with a few exceptions
such as the Alward (2001) web page which points out, "Laura knew
she could not [allow herself to] be captured. In those days the
punishment for spies was death by firing squad," the notion of treason
or related issues are rarely addressed in the web-based accounts
of Laura Secord's war-related activities.
|
10
|
| |
|
How Did Laura Learn of the
Americans Proposed Attack?
|
|
|
Accounts vary. As the six excerpts
from web pages and sites below demonstrate, more versions of how
Laura Secord learned of the American plan to attack Beaver Dams
seem to exist than varieties of chocolates included in a Laura Secord
Sampler. The authors of the pages and sites themselves, moreover,
likewise are comprised of an eclectic mix of individuals of varying
ages and educational levels.
|
11
|
|
Version A: "In late June 1813
Laura Ingersoll Secord awoke one morning to find her small village,
Queenston, Upper Canada, surrounded and taken over by invading Americans.
With 600 men and two artillery pieces they were planning a surprise
attack on Lieut. FitzGibbons at Dew Cew Falls 20 miles to the west"
(Source: Harley, J., Canada's Joan-of-Arc. One of a number
of stories included on the Mysteries of Canada web site).
|
12
|
|
Version B: "In 1813, Laura's
hometown of Queenston, Ontario was American occupied. Forced to
provide food for enemy soldiers late one summer's evening, she stole
outside to listen to what they said. She learned that shortly the
Americans were to ambush British troops at nearby Beaver Dams. Someone
had to warn the British, quickly. As her husband was convalescing
from another battle, Laura decided to go herself" (Source: New Westminster
School District 40, Pearson Adult Learning Center. Weekly feature
Laura Secord: A great Canadian: Jennifer's weekly feature. Retrieved
from <
http://palc.sd40.bc.ca/palc/feature/02-01/laurasecord.htm
>).
|
13
|
|
Version C: "The American troops
moved into people's homes and took over the household. Because of
three [sic] soldiers, the Secord's [sic] had to live in only the
kitchen and one bedroom. The Secord's [sic] had to liked [sic] like
servants for the American men like providing them food. The men
would usually talk about military matters and stuff like that. On
June 21, 1813, the American soldiers were talking to their commander
over dinner. Laura overheard the conversation and was terrified
to here [sic] the men were planning a surprise attack on Canadian
forces near a place called Beaver Dams.... Laura memorized what
they were planning and told her family what must be done. One of
them had to go to Lieutenant FitzGibbon of the Canadian troops and
tell him about the Americans' plans (Source: Laura Ingersoll
Secord. Retrieved from <http://www.rockyview.ab.ca/bpeak/>.
Note: The information was provided by a primary student in Alberta).
|
14
|
|
Version D: "On June 21, 1813,
the Secords were ordered to provide shelter to some American soldiers.
The soldiers led by Captain Gyrenius Chapin were secretly planning
an assault against Lt. James Fitzgibbon at Beaverdams. That evening,
the soldiers drank too much and became boisterous and bragged of
their plans to crush the British that remained in the area. Laura
and her husband overheard their plans.... Upon hearing the plan,
the Secords knew that Fitzgibbon must be warned" (Source: Carrol,
C. Who is Laura Secord? Retrieved from <
http://mdmd.essortment.com/whoislaurasec_rjcg.htm
>).
|
15
|
|
Version E: "May of 1812....
The invading troops needed shelter and three soldiers moved into
the small Secord home and confined the Secords to the kitchen and
one small bedroom. They had to provide dinner for the soldiers,
while they discussed military matters over dinner. One day, the
soldiers invited Colonel Boerstler to dinner and they talked about
the war and army strategies. Laura overheard them talk about a surprise
attack on Beaver Dams the next day, which was under the control
of Lieutenant James FitzGibbon.... James and Laura decided that
someone must warn FitzGibbon, but it was impossible for James to
go, so Laura planned to warn him herself" (Source: Thomson CI Web
Spinners. Laura Secord homepage. Retrieved from <http://schools.tdsb.on.ca/dmthomson/>.
Note: The Thomson CI Web Spinners are a group of Ontario secondary
students).
|
16
|
|
Version F: "The American officers
came to the Secords' [home] and insisted Laura serve them dinner.
Food was plentiful. The wine flowed. The officers became careless
and boasted that they were going to attack the British and Canadians
at Beaver Dams. Colonel Boerstler planned to attack Lieutenant Fitzgibbon
and destroy his headquarters and take the detachment that was protecting
the military equipment captive. Laura knew if Fitzgibbons wasn't
warned, the entire Niagara Peninsula would be lost. Laura talked
to James. He was unable to go. Laura, to James' dismay, decided
she would make the trek. At dawn the following morning, Laura began
her journey" (Source: Alward, M. Laura Secord. Retrieved
from <
http://la.essortment.com/laurasecord_raee.htm
>).
|
17
|
|
The above versions generally agree
on the following aspects of the Laura Secord story: 1) At the time
of Laura Secord's journey, Queenston was occupied by American troops,
2) Laura was married to James Secord who was wounded in an earlier
battle (Queenston Heights in 1812), 3) By some means (a point of
dispute among the sources), Laura overheard American soldiers planning
an attack on the British forces, and 4) She intended to warn the
British of the Americans' plan. Nevertheless, beyond basic agreement
upon these four facets of the story, the web pages differ—at
times markedly—in their depictions of other aspects of the
story as shown in
Figure 1
. Interestingly, relatively few of the web-based accounts note the
existence of multiple plausible versions of the story.
|
18
|
Figure 1. Selected Aspects of the Laura Secord Story
|
| Source |
Terms used to Refer to Laura Secord |
Time Laura Secord Left on Her Journey |
Length of Journey to Canadian Forces |
Keywords Used to Describe Journey |
Laura Secord's Dress/Appearance |
Description of Indians' Assistance |
References to Differing Interpretations of
Her Actions |
| Her Story Women |
|
4 a.m. |
20 miles |
swamps, rain-swollen creeks, up the Niagara
Escarpment |
|
Mention of Six Nation allies lout no mention
of any confrontation with L. Secord |
None |
| Laura Secord (M. Alward) |
"heroic trek;" "famous act of patriotism" |
"crack of dawn" |
|
"wildcats, wolves and rattlesnakes ...at that
time, the Niagara Peninsula was full of them";
"crossed over fields";
"waded through swamps"; "hot sun beat down upon her";
"brambles tore at her clothes"; "climbed a steep escapement";
"forged ahead through the deep undergrowth" |
"dressed in a cotton dress with a long straight
skirt and white bonnet. On her feet, Laura wore slippers of
light kid with low heels and with ties at the instep"; "It
is believed that at some point she lost the kid slippers she
was wearing and continued her trek in bare feet." "Her clothes
were town and bedraggled and her feet were bare" |
"Upon entering a clearing, Laura found her
self surrounded by Indians. Though she trembled in fear, Laura
didn't panic. Somehow she made the chief understand the urgercy
of the situation. according to her own account, the chief
escorted her to Beaver Dams and to Lieutenant Fitzgibbon.' |
"Laura knew she could not be captured. In those
days the punishment for spies was death by firing squad." |
| War of 1812 People & Stories: Laura Secord |
|
"left before sunrise" |
'Walked for 18 hours"; "20 mile cross trek" |
"through swamp, brush and farmland"; "braved
the blazing June sun and potential for wild animals" |
"...wore her secondbest dress, low-buckled
shoes, and cotton sunbonnet" |
"Near the end of her journey she encountered
some native warriors and asked them to take her to Fitzgibbon's
headquarters." |
|
| Laura Ingersoll Secord |
|
"On June 22, 1813, Laura began her, long walk" |
|
"dangerous animals lived in the area"; "Laura
and Elizabeth got caught in a bog and were slowly sinking" |
|
".. surrounded by frightening looking Mohawks
and Caughnawagas"; "Native people kind enough to bring her
to the Decew House where FitzGibbon was." |
|
|
|
A web site devoted to the War of
1812 created by Galafilm, a Canadian film production company to
accompany a film about the War, is one of the few web pages/sites
found during the web exploration that provide quotes from primary
source materials associated with Laura Secord, such as the text
of the memorial Laura presented to the Prince of Wales in 1860 that
described her wartime service. The site also offers a number of
other period documents as well as a collection of war-related images
of paintings, drawings and etchings. In addition, the site also
offers a Historian's Perspective page which includes several
questions regarding the Laura Secord legend posed to Canadian historian
George Sheppard along with his responses to them. Sheppard was first
asked whether the story of Laura Secord was actually true. He replied,
"For the most part, it seems to ring true." He then discussed how
a cow became a part of the legend thanks to an 1860s historian and
the historical debate over the effectiveness of Secord's warning.
The second question posed to Sheppard was whether Canadians living
in the 1860s and thereafter needed to have a heroine from the War
of 1812. He responded in part:
you've got people, by the 1860s, who are looking for
heroines or heroes that they can put forth to the population and
say, 'Look it. We are Canadians, we have done this in the past.
We've thrown back...—it's especially nice that you're throwing
back the Americans, you know...' (The War of 1812: Historian's
Perspective. Retrieved from <
http://www.galafilm.com/1812/e/background/hist_secord.html
>).
|
19
|
|
The Galafilms site, unlike most of
its web counterparts, to some extent addresses the issue of whether
Secord was intentionally vague about how she learned of the Americans'
plans. This is a topic, however, more likely to be covered in book-length
treatments of the War of 1812 and of Laura Secord than in web-based
accounts. For example, in Flames Across the Border, Pierre
Berton suggests Laura Secord's circumspection and vagueness concerning
her source for the American plans were due to the fact that it was
"not in her interest to give her source" since her informant may
quite possibly have been an American still living in the United
States. If this was indeed the case, the individual—if found
out—would have been charged with treason (Berton, 1981, p.
84, The Devil is in the Details).
|
20
|
|
Although Laura's story is rife with
ambiguities and uncertainties, extremely detailed accounts of her
journey are available on the web. For example, in several instances,
authors relate that Laura "set off at 4:00 am to warn the Canadian
forces of the upcoming attack" (Her Story Women. Retrieved
from
>; C. Carroll, Who is Laura Secord?). Others provide intricate
details about the clothes she wore on her June 1813 trek. M. Alward's
Larua Secord page, for example, describes Laura's clothing
during the different stages of her journey. When she sets off on
her journey, readers are informed that she was "dressed in a cotton
dress with a long straight skirt and white bonnet. On her feet...slippers
of light kid with low heels and with ties at the instep." Later
we are told, "It is believed that at some point she lost the kid
slippers she was wearing and continued her trek in bare feet," and
that by the time she reached Fitzgibbon, "her clothes were torn
and bedraggled and her feet were bare" (Alward, M., 2001).
|
21
|
Some accounts of Laura's journey
remind one of a combination of modern-day television shows such
as Crocodile Hunter and Survivor. One page notes that
"She made the 20-mile journey across swamps, rain-swollen creeks
and up the Niagara escarpment to find the Canadian forces" (Her
Story Women
>). Another not only offers an even more heart-pounding account
but also adds a companion for a portion of the trek—Laura's
niece Elizabeth:
Laura and Elizabeth finally got out of the swamp but
that was only half of the journey, there was still 'The Mountain'
(local name for the Niagara Escarpment which is steep and covered
with dense forest). Elizabeth stayed behind for she was too tired
to continue on with Laura, Laura understood and went up the Mountain
by herself. Her climb was a difficult one, flooded creeks trying
to sweep her away and logs with broken branches covering her bare
foot (Laura Ingersoll Secord).
2
Despite the widely varying accounts of Laura's journey,
however, one crucial aspect of the story remains unfailingly constant
throughout—Laura Secord successfully achieves her goal of
reaching Lieutenant FitzGibbon and alerting him to the American
plans. With this news in hand, FitzGibbon's British troops and their
native compatriots later succeed in surprising the Americans and
ultimately win the Battle of Beaver Dams.
|
22
|
| |
|
Lessons the Laura Secord Project
Can Teach
|
|
|
|
23
|
|
Scouring the web for information
on Laura Secord yielded a number of observations which are applicable
to any web-based research foray. Admittedly, the challenges involved
in undertaking web-based historical research on Laura Secord or
any other topic is at times fraught with danger and uncertainties
just as the legendary journey examined in this paper. These uncertainties
include the difficulty in establishing the authorship of many web
pages/sites. Moreover, even if an author's name is included, his/her
qualifications for writing about the topic are frequently absent.
For example, out of twelve web pages/sites devoted to Laura Secord
analyzed in depth for the essay, only five included author attributions
and none of the pages/sites offered any information about the named
authors. In comparison, the majority of printed works devoted to
Laura Secord which were consulted (especially those published in
the last few decades) included at least a brief biographical statement
about the author. Another noticeable departure from print-based
scholarly publications is the relative lack of documentation for
sources of information used in writing web pages/sites. In some
instances, bibliographies of works are included with pages/sites
but this occurs all too infrequently.
|
24
|
|
However, in response to critics who
decry the questionable quality of the information provided on the
web, it should be noted that wide variations in the depiction of
Laura Secord also were found in the print sources consulted including
those published by university and other "reputable" publishers.
In addition, although many histories of the War include bibliographies
of works cited at the end of the book many also lack pinpointed
cites of sources. Web-based information tends to be of the unfiltered
variety whereas in the print world at least some type of gatekeeper
such as an editor and/or peer review process is undertaken to ascertain
whether a work meets a prerequisite set of standards for publication.
Nonetheless, traditional publishing practices also do not always
insure the accuracy or overall quality of information. In the end,
it must be remembered that information of dubious as well as high
quality can be disseminated via any format or medium.
|
25
|
|
As a general observation, the web
pages/sites visited tended to offer a more "black and white" version
of the Laura Secord legend and largely avoided addressing the many
historical debates surrounding the story. Although the Alward account
indicates that a controversy over the story exists, it claims that
divergent accounts begin at the point where Laura sets off on her
journey and not earlier. However, as the examples demonstrate, discrepancies
begin cropping up very early in the story.
|
26
|
Despite the many historical uncertainties
surrounding Laura Secord's trek, one young web author observed:
I REALLY like this girl. She did what people thought
back then women couldn't do. She was loyal, strong, brave, and
true. She saved her husband and saved the country that allowed
her to live [sic] in peace. I think we need more women like Laura
around don't you? (Laura Ingersoll Secord)
Arguably, these simple words capture the essence of the
Laura Secord legend whether it's retold in a book, a play, a song,
or on a web page. Laura Secord offers a good story about a Canadian
woman who through tenacity and determination defeats the odds and
beats the Americans. It's a great Loyalist tale if ever there was
one.
|
27
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
Notes
1. Laura Secord®,
the leading retailer of boxed chocolates in Canada, was founded
in 1913 by Frank O'Connor and was named after Laura Secord which
the company describes as "...a Canadian icon of courage, devotion
and loyalty." "Laura Secord® products are distributed through
175 company-operated retail stores and selected drug and department
stores." (Source: Fannie May Candies: Company History)
Adding a bit of historical irony to the story, in June 1999, the
previously Canadian-owned Laura Secord company was purchased by
the Chicago-based Archibald Candy Corporation.
2. This particular
account has Laura losing a shoe sometime earlier when she "got
caught in a bog" and was slowly sinking.
References
Berton, P. (1981). Flames across the border:
The Canadian-American tragedy, 1813–1814. Boston: Little,
Brown.
Brown, C. (Ed.). (2000). The illustrated history
of Canada. Toronto, ON: Key Porter Books.
Hickey, D. R. (1990). The War of 1812: A forgotten
conflict. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
Kingsford, W. (1968). The history of Canada
(Vol. 8, 1808–1815). New York: AMS Press.
MacKirdy, K. A., Zoltvany, Y. F., & Moir, J. S.
(Eds.). (1967). Changing perspectives in Canadian history.
Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.
Mahon, J. K. (1972). The War of 1812. Gainesville,
FL: University of Florida Press.
McKenzie, R. (1976). Ingersoll, Laura (Secord).
In Dictionary of Canadian Biography (Vol. 9). Toronto, ON:
University of Toronto Press.
Moore, C. (1994). The Loyalists: Revolution,
exile, settlement. Toronto, ON: McClelland & Stewart.
O'Malley, Michael, & Rosenzweig, R. (1997, June).
Brave new world or blind alley? American history on the World Wide
Web. Journal of American History, 84(1), 21 printed pages.
Wallace, W. S. (Ed.). (1963). The Macmillan dictionary
of Canadian biography (3rd ed., rev. & enl.). London: Macmillan.
Appendix A
Web Pages/Sites Related to Laura Secord Consulted
for the Paper
Archibald Candy Company. (2002). Fannie May Candies: Company
history. Retrieved April 30, 2002 from <http://www.fanniemay.com/static/company_history_form.asp>.
Alward, M. (2001). Laura Secord. Retrieved April 25, 2002,
from <http://la.essortment.com/laurasecord_raee.htm>.
A brief survey of the la.essortment.com home page brings up a
listing of a bizarre array of links to topics ranging from "Garbanzo
bean soup recipe," "How to stop dog from digging," and "What is
waterbirth and is it for you?" to "Character analysis of Shakespeare's
Hamlet and Othello" and "Pablo Picasso biography." At the bottom
of the Laura Secord page is a group of FAQs, one of which asks:
"Want more info on the author of the article?" When the link is
followed, a message pops up which states, "Our privacy policy
prevents us from giving out any information about any of our authors.
Some of the articles have an author's name on them—it has
been included at their request. Some of them do not have the authors
name, again, at the authors request. In either case, we do not
give out any additional information."
Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. Laura Secord. Retrieved
April 25, 2002, from <http://www.cbc4kids.ca/general/time/history-challenge/winner2/secord.html>.
Carroll, C. Who is Laura Secord? Retrieved April 30, 2002,
from <http://mdmd.essortment.com/whoislaurasec_rjcg.htm>.
Galafilm. The War of 1812, People & Stories: Laura Secord.
Retrieved May 2, 2002, from <http://www.galafilm.com/1812/people/secord.html>.
Harley, J. Canada's Joan-of-Arc. In Mysteries of Canada.
Retrieved January 28, 2004, from <http://www.mysteriesofcanada.com/Ontario/secord.htm>.
Her Story Women. Retrieved April 2002, from <http://www.niagara.com/~merrwill/herwomen.html>.
Heritage Minutes: Laura Secord. Retrieved April 30, 2002,
from <http://www.histori.ca/historica/eng_site/minutes/minutes_online/secord.html>.
Web page provides excerpt on Laura Secord from The Heritage
Post. 7th ed.
Laura Secord. Retrieved May 2, 2002, from <http://members.tripod.com/~war1812/secord.html>.
Laura Ingersoll Secord. Retrieved May 2, 2002, from <http://www.rockyview.ab.ca/bpeak/students/canada/kasecord.html>.
New Westminster School District 40, Pearson Adult Learning Centre.
(2002, February 10). Laura Secord: A great Canadian : Jennifer's
weekly feature. Retrieved January 28, 2004, from <http://palc.sd40.bc.ca/palc/feature/02-01/laurasecord.htm>.
Schulze, L. M. (2001). The Canadian Military Heritage Project:
Laura Secord. Retrieved May 2, 2002, from <http://www.rootsweb.com/~canmil/1812/bios/laura.html>.
Thomson C.I. Web Spinners. Laura Secord Homepage. Retrieved
from <http://schools.tdsb.on.ca/dmthomson/secord/index.htm>.
Note: Web page created by students at David and Mary Thomson C.I.,
a secondary school in Ontario.
Appendix B
Works Related to Laura Secord Beyond the Web
A.I.D. International & I. H. Enterprises. (1977). The War
of 1812. London, ON: A.I.D. International. A set of filmstrips
and sound cassettes about the War of 1812 for use in schools.
One segment of the work is devoted to Laura Secord.
Alberta, S. (1960). Canada, my homeland. Montréal:
RCA. A 33 1/3 album by Canadian musician "Alberta Slim" which
includes the song, "The Laura Secord Story."
Barnes, C. (1981). Laura Secord. Ottawa, ON: Canadian
Library Association. One of a number of readers on different subjects
designed for "new literates" in adult literacy courses initiated
and designed by the London (ON) Council for Adult Education.
Bassett, J. M., & Petrie, A. R. (2004). Laura Secord (Rev.
ed.). Markham, ON: Fitzhenry & Whiteside. A children's book about
Laura Secord, originally published in the 1970s. In 1981 the work
was reprinted under the title Laura Secord as a part of
The Canadians series. In 2004, a revised edition was published
as a part of The Canadians series.
Boyko-Head, C. A. (1995). The myth of Laura Secord in nineteenth-century
artistic (re)presentations to twentieth-century popular culture.
Hamilton, ON: McMaster University, Department of English. A Ph.D.
dissertation about the Laura Secord myth.
Brundle, J. (1949). Laura, the heroine of Beaver Dam, June
24th, 1813. Roche's Point, ON. A poetic take on Laura Secord.
Canadian Home Economics Association & Laura Secord Candy Shops.
(1966). The Laura Secord Canadian cook book. Toronto, ON:
McClelland and Stewart. One of a number of Laura Secord cookbooks
published through the years in Canada.
Carnochan, J. (1913). Laura Secord monument at Lundy's Lane.
A Niagara Historical Society (Niagara, ON) publication which discusses
the Laura Secord monument erected at Lundy's Lane.
Coates, C. M., & Morgan, C. L. (2002). Heroines and history:
Madeleine de Vercheres and Laura Secord. Toronto, ON: University
of Toronto Press. Scholarly biographies of Madeleine de Vercheres
and Laura Secord.
Crook, C. B. (1993). Laura's choice: The story of Laura Secord.
Winnipeg, MB: Windflower Communications. A fictional account of
Laura Secord for juvenile readers.
Crook, C. B., & Lawrason, J. (2000). Laura Secord's brave
walk. Toronto, ON: Second Story Press. A fictionalized account
of Laura Secord's 1813 journey.
Cruikshank, E. A., et al. (1892). Lundy's Lane Historical
Society documents, 1812–1815. Welland, ON: Lundy's Lane
Historical Society. Documents include the "Story of Laura Secord."
Currie, E. A. (1900). The story of Laura Secord and Canadian
reminiscences. Toronto, ON: W. Briggs. A component of the
History of Women microfilm series.
Curzon, S. A. (1887). Laura Secord, the heroine of 1812: A
drama; and other poems. Toronto, ON: C. Blackett Robinson.
A set of poems and fables of both English and French origins which
represents one of the earlier collections devoted to Laura Secord.
Curzon, S. A. (1891). The story of Laura Secord, 1813.
Toronto, ON: Williamson. A fifteen page biography of Laura Secord
published under the auspices of the Lundy's Lane historical society
in July, 1891.
Denison, M. (1931). Henry Hudson and other plays: Six plays
for the microphone from the Romance of Canada series of radio
broadcasts. Toronto, ON: The Ryerson Press. A script of a
radio play "Laura Secord" from the Romance of Canada series radio
broadcasts. The broadcasts were "based on historic episodes in
the Canadian past."
Foundation, C. (1998). Minute by minute the making of a Canadian
mythology. In Making of a Canadian mythology; CRB Foundation
heritage minutes. Montréal, QE: Corvideocom Ltd. "Laura
Secord" would provide the topic for one of The Heritage minutes
that appeared on Canadian television during the early 1990s.
Friesen, C. A. (2000). The lady with the bonnet: The story
of Laura Secord. St. Catharines, ON: Niagara Pub. Another
recent work of juvenile fiction written about Laura Secord.
Grol, L. R. (1994). Laura Secord and boastful Alice: A one
act play. Fonthill, ON: Trillium Books. A children's play
based upon Laura Secord.
Grol, L. R. (1997). The Battle of Beaverdam: a historical
drama in three acts. Guelph, Ont., Questex. A historical theatrical
drama featuring Laura Secord as a featured protagonist.
Herrington, W. S. (1910). Heroines of Canadian history.
Toronto, ON: Briggs. Laura Secord is one of a number of Canadian
"heroines" whose lives and deeds are recounted in this 1910 work.
Hume, B. (1928). Laura Secord. Toronto, ON: Ryerson Press.
A 1920s biography of Laura Secord.
Lunn, J., & Newhouse, M. (2001). Laura Secord: A story of
courage. Toronto, ON: Tundra Books. Yet another recent fictionalized
account of Laura Secord for children.
McKenzie, R. (1972). Laura Secord: The legend and the lady.
Toronto, ON: McClelland and Stewart. A 1970s look at the Laura
Secord legend.
McLeod, C. (1983). Legendary Canadian women. Hantsport,
N.S.: Lancelot Press. Biographies of a number of Canadian women
including Laura Secord.
Montgomery, L. M., & MacGregor, M. E. M., et al. (1934). Courageous
women. Toronto, ON: McClelland & Stewart. Yet another biography
of Canadian women including Laura Secord. The work was coauthored
by noted Canadian writer, Lucy Maude Montgomery.
Parr, J., & Rosenfeld, M. (1996). Gender and history in Canada.
Toronto, ON: Copp Clark Ltd. A feminist view of Laura Secord is
offered by Madge Pon in her chapter contribution, "'Of slender
frame and delicate appearance': the placing of Laura Secord in
the narratives of Canadian loyalist history."
Price-Brown, J. (1930). Laura, the undaunted; A Canadian historical
romance. Toronto, ON: Ryerson Press. A fictionalized account
of Laura Secord written in 1930.
Robinson, H. C. (1981). Laura, a portrait of Laura Secord.
Toronto, ON: Dundurn Press. A volume in the Canadian heroines
series, this biography of Laura Secord was written for juvenile
readers.
Roussin, C. (1975). Marche, Laura Secord! Montréal,
QE: L'Aurore distribution Agence de distribution populaire. A
French-language play based upon the life and times of Laura Secord.
It is part of the collection Entre le parvis et le boxon (no.
14).
Swain, S. S. (1927). The story of Laura Secord and Fanny Doyle:
Heroines of the Niagara frontier. Buffalo, NY: [s.n.]. Includes
short biographical sketches of Laura Secord and Fanny Doyle.
Thompson, E. J., Mrs, et al. (1913). Laura Ingersoll Secord:
Monument at Lundy's Lane; Queenston in early years; Diary of a
prisoner in Red River Rebellion. Niagara, ON: Niagara Historical
Society. Published by the Niagara Historical Society, the work
includes several chapters related to Laura Secord including "Laura
Secord" by Mrs.E.J. Thompson as well as a chapter on the Laura
Secord monument at Lundy's Lane by Janet Carnochan.
Trottier, M. and K. Reczuch (2000). Laura's journey : a childhood
tale of Laura Secord. Markham, ON: North Winds Press. A children's
book featuring a tale about a young Laura Secord and her lost
cow.
Un récit canadien. (1950). Canada, my homeland, Québec.
Wagner, A. (1979). Women pioneers. Toronto, ON: Canadian
Theatre Review Publications. A volume in the Canada's Lost Plays
series (v. 2), this work is a compilation of Canadian plays including
S. A. Curzon's "Laura Secord, the heroine of 1812."
Wallace, W. S. (1932). The story of Laura Secord: a study
in historical evidence. Toronto, ON: The Macmillan Company
of Canada Limited. Stewart takes a critical look at Laura Secord's
activities related to the Battle of Beaver Dams.
|
Content in the History Cooperative database is intended for personal, noncommercial use only. You may not reproduce, publish, distribute, transmit, participate in the transfer or sale of, modify, create derivative works from, display, or in any way exploit the History Cooperative database in whole or in part without the written permission of the copyright holder.
|