|
|
|
Book Reviews
| Dugald Gardner, Surgeon, Scientist, Soldier: The Life and Times of Henry Wade 1876–1955 (London: Royal Society of Medicine Press, 2005) ISBN I-85315-661-2. xvii + 437 pp.
|
| I began reading this biography with considerable anticipation, an appetite whetted by the clear print and lavish illustrations, and by the promise in the foreword that Wade had enjoyed five lives: as a 'scientist and pathological expert in the biology of cancer, a master of the complex and exacting field of surgical urology, a military surgeon in the tradition of Dominique Larrey, a museum conservator of distinction and an antiquarian.' |
1
|
|
Wade, described by the author as an 'archetypal surgeon ... at a time of transition in the world of medicine,' was the son of a United Presbyterian Church minister. Wade and his siblings displayed many of the characteristics of the nineteenth century Scottish eagerness to better themselves by education and / or travel. Two of his brothers became lawyers and another pursued a medical career in Australia; a sister also went to Australia and married a doctor, spawning two more medical men along the way. Henry commenced his medical studies at the Edinburgh Medical School in 1893 and graduated five years later. |
2
|
|
Within eighteen months of graduating he had accepted a post as a civilian surgeon with the British Army during the Anglo-Boer War, and chapter two recounts the field conditions and medical problems facing the doctors involved in this conflict. Two later chapters cover Wade's time with the Royal Army Medical Corps at Gallipoli and in Egypt and Syria during World War I. Four chapters deal with the intervening years from 1902–14 and examine the beginnings of his surgical career, involvement with cancer research and laboratory science in Edinburgh, and his time as curator of the museum of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh. The second half of the text pursues Wade's post-war career as a surgeon, his role as a university teacher and examiner, and his bureaucratic contribution as a College councillor and president (1935–37). |
3
|
|
One of the arts of the biographer is to engage with his or her subject and flesh out the bare bones of a career. Sadly, Dugald Gardner fails to achieve this. There is little sense of Wade the man; the closest we come to this is the penultimate chapter which describes his marriage late in life and the early death of his wife before turning to an account of Wade's antiquarian interests around the history of his house near Haddington—something entirely peripheral to his surgical career. |
4
|
|
Almost all of the chapters within the book focus more on the institutions to which Wade was attached than on his contributions to medicine and surgery. The text is littered with irrelevant information, much of pertaining to periods beyond the span of Wade's life. Why, for example, are we informed of the number of coal fires and gas mantles in the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh in the 1870s and the electric lamps which replaced then in the 1890s (pp. 10–1, 43–4)? Again, why tell the reader how many ships docked in Leith in 1844 in the section covering Wade's appointment to Leith Hospital in 1908? |
5
|
|
This self-indulgence extends throughout the text and is coupled with an often muddled chronology. The section on postgraduate examinations, for example, jumps successively to 1931, 1921, 1954, 1902, 1918, 1900, 1938 and 1943, with no indication as to whether Wade was involved in any of the events listed. |
6
|
|
The author has been poorly advised by his publishers, or has chosen to ignore their advice. The text is indiscriminately littered with both endnotes and footnotes, many of which have limited relevance to the main themes. A third set of references appear as appendices; many of these, including the two–page biography of Larrey (pp. 394–5), fall into the same category. Amidst all of this, there is a signal failure to place Wade at the centre of his own story. In many sections, his is an unseen figure and an unheard voice. |
7
|
In contrast to my initial expectations, I laid down Wade's biography some 450 pages later with a feeling of profound disappointment.
|
8
|
| DEREK DOW
|
| UNIVERSITY OF AUCKLAND |
|
Content in the History Cooperative database is intended for personal, noncommercial use only. You may not reproduce, publish, distribute, transmit, participate in the transfer or sale of, modify, create derivative works from, display, or in any way exploit the History Cooperative database in whole or in part without the written permission of the copyright holder.
|